The token allocation in Medieval Empires is not transparent, as specific percentages for team, advisor, and investor allocations are missing, making it difficult to assess fairness.
The vesting schedules are unclear, with no details provided on whether they use linear, graded, or cliff-based mechanisms. This lack of information prevents a proper evaluation of their alignment with long-term goals.
The small public round allocation of 2.9% indicates limited community participation, although this alone does not signify unfairness.
There is no indication of performance-based unlocks or measures to ensure team commitment during the vesting period, which raises concerns about long-term alignment.
The lack of detailed information makes it impossible to rule out the possibility of token concentration or dumping risks, which could negatively impact the game's economy.
The absence of clear communication about allocation details and any changes further detracts from transparency and fairness.
Given the lack of transparency and detailed information, the token allocation and vesting schedule fall significantly below industry standards and fail to align with the rubric's criteria for a higher score.
Introduction
Token allocation and vesting schedules are critical components of any Web3 game's economic structure, as they directly impact the fairness, transparency, and long-term viability of the project.
For Medieval Empires, evaluating these mechanisms is essential to determine whether the project aligns team incentives with long-term success while protecting the interests of other stakeholders.
This report will cover:
The distribution of tokens among key stakeholders and the implications for fairness.
The vesting schedules in place and their alignment with long-term project goals.
Any potential risks or red flags in the token allocation and vesting system.
Token Distribution Among Stakeholders
The distribution of tokens in Medieval Empires appears to involve multiple rounds of funding, including seed/private and public rounds, but specific allocation percentages are not detailed in the provided sources.
[1a][1b]
Public round allocations constitute 2.9% of the total token distribution, indicating a relatively small portion allocated to the public.
[1b]
Data on team, advisor, and investor allocations is missing, making it difficult to assess whether the majority of tokens are concentrated among a few stakeholders.
Vesting Schedules and Long-Term Alignment
The sources do not provide explicit details on the vesting schedules for Medieval Empires, making it challenging to evaluate their structure and alignment with long-term goals.
There is no indication of whether the vesting schedules use linear, graded, or cliff-based mechanisms.
The absence of performance-based unlocks or measures to ensure team commitment during the vesting period cannot be confirmed or analyzed.
Potential Risks and Red Flags
While the sources do not indicate any immediate red flags, the lack of transparency in token distribution and vesting schedules raises concerns about fairness and long-term alignment.
The small public round allocation (2.9%) may limit broader community participation, though this does not necessarily indicate unfairness.
[1b]
Without clear details on team and investor allocations, it is impossible to rule out the possibility of token concentration or dumping risks.
Conclusion
The token allocation and vesting schedule of Medieval Empires remain unclear based on the provided sources, limiting the ability to assess their fairness, transparency, and strategic alignment.
While no immediate red flags are evident, the lack of detailed information raises concerns about potential risks and long-term sustainability.
Further details on team, advisor, and investor allocations are necessary to evaluate fairness and prevent token concentration.
Clarification of vesting schedules, including their structure and alignment with long-term goals, is essential for a comprehensive assessment.
References
[1] medievalempires.com.The flawless and strong Tokenomics design of our game is one of our core strengths.medievalempires.com. Available from: https://medievalempires.com/tokenomics/
