

Significance
Project Matthew's community strategy is crucial for fostering player engagement, driving growth, and ensuring long-term success in the Web3 gaming space. However, the game faces significant challenges in creating a cohesive and supportive ecosystem due to ineffective influencer partnerships, platform management issues, and a lack of transparency.
- Project Matthew's influencer strategy has been marred by controversies, such as misleading promotions, which have damaged the game's reputation and failed to drive meaningful player acquisition or retention.
- On Discord, the community has been plagued by toxicity, spam, and misinformation, with new players often left without adequate guidance, undermining the platform's potential as a community hub.
- Telegram has been criticized for slow response times and lack of official engagement, leading to frustration among community members and weakening its role as a communication channel.
- The lack of transparency and slow developer-community interaction has eroded trust in the development team, with instances of feedback being ignored or dismissed, further isolating the community.
- Despite these challenges, Project Matthew's strong focus on community events and a high player retention rate of 80% suggests potential for improvement if these issues are addressed.
Completeness
The research provides a critical analysis of Project Matthew's community strategy but lacks detailed information on some key areas, limiting the ability to fully assess its effectiveness.
- The absence of specific data on influencer collaborations, such as the identities of key influencers and the nature of their partnerships, makes it difficult to evaluate their impact on player acquisition and retention.
- Limited information on Telegram's activities, including metrics like member count and engagement levels, hinders a comprehensive evaluation of the platform's effectiveness in fostering community growth.
- Further insights into Discord's channel organization, such as the types of channels available and moderation practices, would provide a clearer picture of its functionality as a community hub.
- Additional research into the frequency and quality of developer interactions across all platforms would help determine the extent of their engagement with the community.