Golden Tides, a pirate-themed MOBA game, exhibits several flaws that could hinder its success in the competitive Web3 gaming landscape. While the game integrates blockchain elements and offers a unique gameplay experience, concerns around accessibility, economic balance, and technical execution could limit its long-term viability. This report will cover:

• The game’s steep learning curve and reliance on team-based strategies, which may deter casual players.
• Economic imbalances resulting from the reliance on premium servers and exclusive rewards for ship NFT owners.
• The limited utility of NFTs, which primarily serve cosmetic purposes and may not significantly enhance gameplay.
• Concerns about technical execution, including potential delays in development milestones and lack of detailed roadmap progress tracking.